Seasonal Spuds Logo

Sweet Potato Pie

It's always the right time for a slice of something nice like our Sweet Potato Pie which is sure to leave you wanting more.

This recipe was created by Lissa Wu - Recipe Developer.



volume control





20 minutes

cooking time


1 hour 50 minutes



Serves 8


  • 3 sweet potatoes (900g) 
  • 150g butter (melted) 
  • 150g brown sugar  
  • 300ml evaporated milk  
  • 2 large eggs  
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract  
  • 1 tsp ground cinnamon 
  • 1/4 salt  
  • 1 ready roll short crust pastry 


  •  10” flan dish 


To serve (optional):  

  • Whipping cream or icing sugar  


Roast the sweet potatoes, prick with a fork a few times before putting in the oven at 220°C / Fan 200°C / Gas 7 degrees for 40 minutes until soft and cooked (this brings out the sweetness in the sweet potatoes) or if you prefer you can boil or microwave. Peel the skin off to discard. Next mash the sweet potato flesh in a large mixing bowl.
Set the oven to 180˚C / Fan 160˚C / Gas 4.
Add the melted butter to the warm mashed sweet potatoes and mix until well combined, add the remaining ingredients, brown sugar, evaporated milk, two eggs, vanilla extract, cinnamon and salt and mix well to form a smooth consistency.
Place the shortcrust pastry onto a pie dish - you can make decorated pie edges or just keep it plain, no need to blind bake, prick with a fork a few times and then pour the sweet potato mixture into the pastry case.
Carefully put in the oven and bake for 1 hour and 10 mins depending on your oven, use a knife to check it’s fully baked – when you pull it out of the pie it will come out clean. Take the sweet potato pie out of the oven it will look quite puffy but will deflate so not to worry, let it cool down before serving with some cream or icing sugar or on its own. Alternatively you can put the sweet potato pie in the fridge to chill for a few hours or overnight before serving.

You might also like...

Cornish New Potato and Mackerel Fish Cakes with Sun-dried Tomato Sauce & Sour Cream

These simple fish cakes are lightly coated in polenta for a crispy finish, and served with a rich sun-dried tomato sauce. They can be made with fresh or smoked mackerel - if using fresh, you’ll need to pan fry or grill first.

Roasted Cornish New Potato, Fennel and Hake Tray Bake

In goes the crispy skinned Cornish New potatoes, then the sweet fennel and finally two fillets of hake along with a tangy wholegrain mustard and fennel seed dressing. One pan - simple cooking at its best. You will need a deep-sized baking dish or tray around 20x26cm for this dish.

Cornish Pasties Puff Pastry-Style with New Potato, Roasted Red Pepper and Feta

It may look like a Cornish pasty on the outside, but on the inside this vegetarian pasty is inspired by Mediterranean flavours combining Cornish New potatoes with roasted pepper and feta. It’s a cinch to make with a cheat of shop bought puff pastry.

Sweet Potato Gnocchi

This simple yet satisfying sweet potato gnocchi recipe makes an ideal delicious dinner dish you will want to make over and over again.

Join our mailing list

For all our latest recipes straight to your inbox, plus giveaways, latest news and more!