Seasonal Spuds Logo

Which are the best potatoes for mashing?

By Luke Willcox – New product development team

The classic side dish of mash has been named Britain’s favourite way to prepare potatoes and a hot topic amongst chefs, home-cooks and foodies alike is how best to prepare it.

The best potatoes for mash

Our advice for the perfect mashed potato is to look at varieties with a smooth textured, buttery-tasting flesh. Red-skinned varieties of potatoes are great for mashing, as they tend to have a slightly denser consistency, which when boiled for mash creates a creamy smooth consistency. Some of the creamier All rounder varieties like Nectar or Georgina are also ideal as they’ll give a rich, naturally buttery-tasting dish.

More floury varieties like Maris Piper or King Edward can be good too, but you need to be careful not to overcook them or you’ll end up with mush, rather than mash.

Try experimenting to see which texture you enjoy best.

Mozart potatoes

Mozart potatoes have a firm, creamy yellow flesh which makes a deliciously velvety smooth mash. Possibly the best-known red-skinned potato, along with Desiree, they’re one of the most popular in the UK. They’re a versatile variety, which holds its shape if cooked in sauces, making them great for gratins and dauphinoise.

Laura potatoes

The Laura potato is a golden-fleshed, red-skinned potato that makes a deliciously buttery mash. Expect a rich taste and slight creaminess to enhance your favourite side dish.

Georgina potatoes

Often sold as Bakers, these bold golden tubers have a creamy texture and a rich buttery taste that makes them ideal for mash too.

Nectar potatoes

Nectar is a brilliantly versatile variety that’s often found in both the All rounders and Bakers sections. It’s smooth and creamy, which is perfect for mash.

8 top tips for making creamy mashed potatoes

The key to creamy mash is the variety of potato used, cooking to just the right point and being firm but gentle.

  • Cut your potatoes into even-sized chunks to ensure they cook consistently without any errant lumps.
  • Start by adding your potatoes to cold water and bring to the boil. Using cold water ensures the outside of your potato chunks will cook at the same rate as the inside, resulting in a more even texture.
  • Boil until tender then drain all the water off. Give them a couple of minutes in the pan with the lid on to steam any remaining water out.
  • Mash first, before adding your extra ingredients.
  • Using equal measurements of milk, cream and a knob of butter will add richness, flavour and a smooth, thick texture. Don’t forget to season with salt and pepper and a handful of chopped herbs such as parsley, to make your dish pop.
  • Using a ricer is also a great way to ensure super smooth, uniform mash if you have this handy piece of kitchen kit.
  • Don’t overdo it – too much mashing can result in a gummy texture. If in doubt, opt for not overworking your mash and be gentle.
  • Make sure you drain your potatoes well to avoid a watery, mushy mess. You can add moisture with milk, butter or cream.

Our best ever mashed potato recipes

Our classic creamy mash recipe is a true crowdpleaser and makes the perfect side dish to any Sunday roast or golden brown pie.

We also recommend trying our mashed potato with wholegrain mustard and parmesan cheese for a luxurious twist on the traditional recipe. You can also top with caramelised red onion to add a hint of sweet and savoury flavour.

If you’re making mash and want to cut down on your food waste, read our guide on how to make the most of potato skins for mouthwatering meal ideas.

Have you got a question you would like our potato experts to answer? Get in touch by tagging @seasonal_spuds on Instagram or by liking us on Facebook.

Check out our recipes!

Sweet potato pumpkin cupcakes on stand
layer

Sweet potato cupcakes

Bake up a batch of these eye-catching Halloween sweet potato cupcakes with cute pumpkin decorations. Ideal for a party buffet or a seasonal sweet treat.
layer

New Potatoes en Papillote

These steamer parcels will keep all the flavour and goodness inside.
layer

Greek-style New potatoes

These delicious potatoes are baked to perfection before getting a sprinkling of feta and fresh thyme.
chinese stir fry
layer

New potatoes in a Chinese-style stir-fry

For a light Chinese-style meal without the rice, this is the perfect way to use up leftover cooked chicken (breast or thigh) and potatoes.
crushed new potatoes with salsa verde
layer

Crushed New potatoes with salsa verde

This potato dish can be used as part of a tapas spread or with the summer barbecue.
roasted new potatoes with lemon and crispy sage
layer

Roasted New potatoes with lemon & crispy sage

Roast potatoes with a refreshing lemon twist adds another dimension to dinner time.
Chicken chorizo and Cornish New potatoes tray roast
layer

Chicken, chorizo and New potatoes tray roast

This healthy one tray roast makes it super easy to cook a roast dinner any day of the week.
honey mustard salmon with new potatoes
layer

Honey mustard salmon with new potatoes

This dish is so easy to make, but seriously impressive, and ready in under 30 minutes.
baked new potatoes with a blue cheese glaze
layer

Baked New Potatoes with a Blue Cheese Glaze

This tasty treat would make a great lunchtime dish, simply served with a green salad.
Loaded Mexican Cornish New potato jackets 
layer

Loaded Mexican Cornish New potato jackets 

Made with fresh peppers, tasty coriander and melted cheese they are perfect for on the go snacking or as a robust side dish.
Cornish New potato and Thai beef salad
layer

Cornish New potato and Thai beef salad

Made with rump steak, fresh mint and red chillies this salad is perfect for both lunch and dinner time.
Cornish New potato and rosemary foccacia
layer

Cornish New potato and rosemary foccacia

Ideal to enjoy with loved ones or as a stand alone snack, this bread is simply delicious.

Related Articles

Potato salad wild garlic pesto

A guide to seasonal vegetables

Posted: December 13, 2022

Our maincrop potatoes grow through the summer and are harvested in the late summer and autumn.You...
Vegan couscous salad with sweet potato

10 Delicious Vegan Potato Recipes

Posted: December 22, 2022

Whether it's for Veganuary or a long-term lifestyle choice, take a look at our tasty vegan-friend...
Easy breakfast potato cakes

Easy leftover mashed potato recipe ideas

Posted: December 23, 2022

Cooking a Sunday dinner or a mid-week roast for the family can often leave you making too many sp...
Potato salad wild garlic pesto

A guide to seasonal vegetables

Posted: December 13, 2022

Our maincrop potatoes grow through the summer and are harvested in the late summer and autumn.You...
Vegan couscous salad with sweet potato

10 Delicious Vegan Potato Recipes

Posted: December 22, 2022

Whether it's for Veganuary or a long-term lifestyle choice, take a look at our tasty vegan-friend...
Easy breakfast potato cakes

Easy leftover mashed potato recipe ideas

Posted: December 23, 2022

Cooking a Sunday dinner or a mid-week roast for the family can often leave you making too many sp...

Join our mailing list

For all our latest recipes straight to your inbox, plus giveaways, latest news and more!